Methodology
How we rate slab pack sites
We rate what happens after the rip, using what operators commit to in writing.
What we rate
| Factor | Weight | What we look at |
|---|---|---|
| Buyback and fees | 30% | The net rate after fees, and whether you're paid in cash or credit. |
| Time and storage | 20% | How long you have to decide, and whether storage is free and open-ended. |
| Provenance | 20% | Is the grader named, are cert numbers shown, are outcomes or values published? |
| First-pack protection | 15% | What's under your first pack, how it's paid, and the conditions attached. |
| Shipping and rewards | 15% | Published shipping costs, and rewards that help people who keep cards. |
The weights guide an editorial rating; they aren't a formula. Two sites with similar terms can differ by a few tenths when one publishes its rules more clearly or treats collectors better.
How we check
Our sources, per operator: its help center, its terms of service, the rules for each promotion, and its app store listing. Affiliate and creator pages serve only as a cross-check. We treat a fact as confirmed when it appears on a page the operator runs; anything we could find only elsewhere is marked as third-party in the review.
So far we have not held accounts, purchased packs or used codes on these platforms. Any review that later draws on that will note it, with the dates.
Rating labels
Our labels borrow the grading scale's names; they aren't grades. 9.0 and up: Gem mint. 8.5 - 8.9: Mint. 8.0 - 8.4: Near mint-mint. 7.5 - 7.9: Near mint. Below 7.5: Excellent-mint.
How often we update
Terms move frequently, so each review is dated. This set of ratings was revised on 19 November 2026.
What doesn't affect a rating
Money. No operator listed here pays BestSlabPacks. Should that change, this notice will be updated, and the ratings will not move because of it.